Entropy and the Second Law of Thermodynamics FRQ Practice

Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.

Question 1 of 5

A sealed, insulated cylinder is divided by a locked partition. Side 1 holds an ideal gas; side 2 is evacuated. The partition is unlocked and the gas expands freely until it fills the cylinder. No energy crosses the outer walls. (a) Identify whether the cylinder as a whole is isolated or closed, and justify. (b) State whether the entropy of the cylinder increases, decreases, or stays the same during the expansion, and justify using the second law. (c) After equilibrium is reached, a student proposes waiting longer “so entropy can fall back.” Explain why that outcome is forbidden for this cylinder.

Question 2 of 5

A refrigerator cools a sealed box of produce. Take the produce and cold interior air as system C. The warm coils and kitchen air that receive rejected heat are surroundings R. Assume matter does not cross the refrigerator cabinet during the interval of interest. (a) Can the entropy of system C decrease while the refrigerator runs? Justify. (b) What qualitative constraint does the second law place on $\Delta S_C + \Delta S_R$? (c) A classmate says “any entropy decrease anywhere is impossible.” Identify the error in that statement.

Question 3 of 5

Two processes take the same sample of gas from the same initial equilibrium state to the same final equilibrium state. Process P is slow and reversible. Process Q is fast and irreversible. (a) Compare $\Delta S$ of the gas for P and for Q. (b) Explain how your comparison uses the idea that entropy is a state function. (c) For which process, if either, is the entropy of an appropriately defined isolated combination that includes the gas and any needed surroundings guaranteed to stay constant?

Question 4 of 5

A hot copper block is dropped into a cooler lake. Eventually both reach a common temperature. Consider three successive descriptions of “the system”: (1) the copper alone, (2) the lake alone, (3) copper plus a large surrounding portion of lake water treated as isolated. (a) For description (1), does entropy increase or decrease during cooling? Justify qualitatively. (b) For description (3), does total entropy increase, decrease, or stay the same? Justify. (c) In a brief phrase, connect your answers to the idea that localized energy tends to disperse.

Question 5 of 5

A growing snow crystal forms on a cold windowpane while the room air is warmer. Treat the crystal as a closed system during a short growth interval. (a) Explain how the crystal’s entropy can decrease even though growth is spontaneous. (b) Identify what must happen to the entropy of the surroundings during that interval for the second law to hold for an isolated combination of crystal plus nearby air. (c) State what is true of the entropy of that isolated combination when growth finally stops and local thermal equilibrium is reached.