Question 1 of 5
(a) Explain why privacy is called unenumerated. (b) Identify the Ninth Amendment’s relevance. (c) Define substantive due process briefly.
Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.
(a) Explain why privacy is called unenumerated. (b) Identify the Ninth Amendment’s relevance. (c) Define substantive due process briefly.
Given the CED’s summary of Griswold v. Connecticut (1965): (a) Describe the government action at a high level. (b) Describe the privacy holding theme. (c) Explain why later disputes can still arise without students memorizing later case names.
Process vs substance:
| Lens | Focus |
|---|---|
| Procedural due process | Fair methods (notice, hearing, counsel) |
| Substantive due process | Whether the rule itself invades liberty |
(a) Identify which lens fits a challenge to a ban’s content rather than hearing procedures. (b) Explain why both lenses can matter in liberty cases. (c) Give one example issue for each lens.
A fictional statute bans private counseling about contraception and provides elaborate hearing procedures before fines. (a) Explain why elaborate procedures may not defeat a substantive due process claim. (b) Identify a privacy interest a challenger would assert (Griswold-style). (c) State a competing state interest neutrally.
Argument: (a) Thesis on judicial recognition of unenumerated privacy. (b) Evidence from Ninth Amendment or implied-rights reasoning. (c) Counterargument about democratic control via legislatures, with response.