Question 1 of 5
(a) Define unenumerated rights. (b) Explain one constitutional argument used to support a right to privacy. (c) Explain what substantive due process examines.
Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.
(a) Define unenumerated rights. (b) Explain one constitutional argument used to support a right to privacy. (c) Explain what substantive due process examines.
Using the CED summary of Griswold v. Connecticut (1965): (a) Identify the privacy-related holding theme. (b) Identify the doctrinal tool (due process). (c) Explain why the word “privacy” need not appear in the Constitution for courts to discuss it.
Debate table:
| Side | Claim |
|---|---|
| A | Privacy should be narrowly limited to textually listed procedures |
| B | Privacy can include intimate decisions inferred from constitutional structure |
(a) Explain Side A’s textual concern. (b) Explain Side B’s interpretive approach. (c) Explain why the CED says protected actions continue to be debated.
A fictional state law criminalizes a private medical consultation about contraception for married adults. The prompt summarizes that a court finds an arbitrary invasion of marital privacy under due process (Griswold-style). (a) Identify substantive due process as the lens. (b) Explain the liberty interest asserted. (c) Explain one competing state interest opponents might claim (public morals/health) without taking a partisan side.
Argument: (a) Thesis on whether courts should recognize unenumerated privacy rights. (b) Use Ninth Amendment or implied-rights reasoning as evidence. (c) Address a counterargument about judicial restraint.