Question 1 of 5
(a) Define selective incorporation. (b) Name one required case that illustrates it. (c) Explain what “selected” means.
Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.
(a) Define selective incorporation. (b) Name one required case that illustrates it. (c) Explain what “selected” means.
Relate McDonald to the Bill of Rights: (a) Identify the amendment incorporated. (b) Explain the pre-incorporation baseline for states. (c) Explain a post-McDonald constraint on states.
Primary source pairing:
| Text | Use in argument |
|---|---|
| 14th Amendment due process | Legal vehicle |
| Letter from a Birmingham Jail | Normative critique of unjust local law |
(a) Explain the legal vehicle’s role in incorporation. (b) Explain how the letter can support a claim about challenging unjust state power. (c) Explain one limit: the letter is not itself a holding that incorporates amendments.
Gideon prompt: (a) State the holding. (b) Explain its incorporation/nationalizing significance. (c) Explain one way it limits state criminal procedure.
Argument: (a) Thesis evaluating selective incorporation’s impact on federalism. (b) Evidence from McDonald or Gideon. (c) Counterargument about state experimentation, with response.