Question 1 of 5
Define and apply. (a) Define stare decisis. (b) Apply it to two similar free-speech cases across Terms. (c) Explain when a Court might still overturn.
Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.
Define and apply. (a) Define stare decisis. (b) Apply it to two similar free-speech cases across Terms. (c) Explain when a Court might still overturn.
Appointments. (a) Identify the two political actors in seating a justice. (b) Explain how ideology enters the process. (c) Explain the stare decisis implication of a transformed majority.
Stability vs change. (a) Explain a cost of never overturning. (b) Explain a cost of frequent overturning. (c) Explain how stare decisis tries to balance those costs.
Doctrine labels.
| Label | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Stare decisis | Respect precedent |
| Appointment power | Pathway to doctrinal change |
(a) Identify which label emphasizes continuity. (b) Identify which emphasizes potential change. (c) Explain how both appear in Topic 2.9.
Scenario. A 6–3 Court signals openness to revisit a 1970s administrative-law precedent after two appointments. (a) Identify the stare decisis question presented. (b) Explain why agencies and Congress suddenly pay attention. (c) Explain one confirmation-hearing question senators might ask future nominees as a result.