Question 1 of 5
Life tenure. (a) Identify how life tenure affects judicial independence. (b) Explain how independence can produce unpopular decisions. (c) Explain why those decisions generate debate about Court power.
Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.
Life tenure. (a) Identify how life tenure affects judicial independence. (b) Explain how independence can produce unpopular decisions. (c) Explain why those decisions generate debate about Court power.
Power debate. (a) Define the counter-majoritarian difficulty in your own words. (b) Give an original scenario of an unpopular holding. (c) Explain one non-violent institutional response other branches might pursue.
Opinion heat map (fictional).
| Group | Approval of Ruling R |
|---|---|
| Party A voters | 22% |
| Party B voters | 71% |
(a) Describe the pattern. (b) Explain how life tenure allows Ruling R to persist despite Party A opposition. (c) Explain how future appointments could still change doctrine.
Independence vs accountability. (a) Explain a benefit of deciding without fear of election loss. (b) Explain a democratic worry about that insulation. (c) Explain how Federalist No. 78 would respond to the worry.
Case comparison prompt. (a) Identify Marbury’s contribution to Court power debates. (b) Explain how a later controversial application of judicial review can intensify legitimacy fights. (c) Explain why summarizing a non-required case’s facts still helps compare holdings.