Challenges of the Articles of Confederation FRQ Practice

Responses receive AI feedback against a rubric after submission. Scores are practice estimates.

Question 1 of 5

(a) Identify the document that created the first U.S. national government after independence. (b) Explain one way lacking interstate commerce power caused problems. (c) Explain one way lacking an executive caused problems.

Question 2 of 5

Ashford Vale comparison.

Capacity Under Articles
National judiciary Absent
Exclusive coinage Absent
Central military response Weak/absent

(a) Identify two absent capacities from the table. (b) Explain how absent exclusive coinage could destabilize the economy. (c) Explain how weak central military response related to Shays’ Rebellion.

Question 3 of 5

A pamphlet urges transferring commerce and enforcement powers to a new national government. (a) Identify the status-quo system the pamphlet criticizes. (b) Explain how the pamphlet’s agenda relates to “powers formerly reserved to the states.” (c) Explain one political argument opponents might make against the transfer.

Question 4 of 5

(a) Identify the weakness shown by inability to compel tax collection nationally. (b) Identify the weakness shown by inability to regulate trade among the states. (c) Explain why either weakness made a lasting union harder to sustain.

Question 5 of 5

Prompt: “Any confederation without a national court is automatically more protective of rights than a constitution with courts.” (a) Identify the Articles’ judicial weakness. (b) Explain one governance problem created by that weakness. (c) Evaluate the prompt with a reason about order, rights, or commercial fairness.