TOPIC 5.12 · STUDY
Exploring Behaviors of Implicit Relations
Implicit differentiation gives slopes on a relation without solving for y. On the circle x^2 + y^2 = 25, y' = -x/y wherever y is not 0. Horizontal tangents are at (0, 5) and (0, -5). Vertical tangents are at (5, 0) and (-5, 0).
FUN-4.D
Exploring Behaviors of Implicit Relations
An implicit relation such as $x^2+y^2=25$ defines $y$ as a function of $x$ only on pieces of the curve. The behaviors of the whole curve, especially horizontal and vertical tangent lines, come from differentiating the equation directly. Treat $y$ as a differentiable function of $x$ on any arc that has a nonvertical tangent, and apply the chain rule to every term that contains $y$. The derivative $y'$ then stays in the equation and can be solved for, as long as its coefficient is not zero.
Differentiate $x^2+y^2=25$ with respect to $x$. The first term contributes $2x$. The second term is a square of a function of $x$, so the chain rule contributes $2y\cdot y'$. The right side is constant, so its derivative is $0$. The differentiated equation is $2x+2yy'=0$. When $y\ne 0$, divide by $2y$ to get $y'=-\frac{x}{y}$. That formula is the slope of the tangent line at any point on the circle whose $y$-coordinate is nonzero.
Example, horizontal tangents. A horizontal tangent has slope $0$, so $-\frac{x}{y}=0$. The numerator must be $0$ while the denominator stays nonzero, which means $x=0$ and $y\ne 0$. Substitute $x=0$ into the original circle: $y^2=25$, so $y=5$ or $y=-5$. Both points are on the curve. At $(0,5)$, $y'=-\frac{0}{5}=0$. At $(0,-5)$, $y'=-\frac{0}{-5}=0$. The tangent lines are the horizontal lines $y=5$ and $y=-5$.
Vertical tangents are the points where this slope formula cannot produce a finite number, and the undifferentiated form $2x+2yy'=0$ confirms why. Set the denominator $y=0$. The circle then gives $x^2=25$, so the points are $(5,0)$ and $(-5,0)$. At $(5,0)$ the differentiated equation becomes $2(5)+2(0)y'=0$, that is $10=0$, which is impossible for every real value of $y'$. The same contradiction appears at $(-5,0)$, where the equation becomes $-10=0$. There is no finite slope. The tangent lines are the vertical lines $x=5$ and $x=-5$. On this circle, whenever $y=0$ the numerator $-x$ is $\pm 5$, so the zero denominator is a vertical tangent.
Solving for $y$ first splits the circle into an upper formula and a lower formula. Each piece stops at $x=\pm 5$, and those endpoints are exactly the vertical tangents of the original curve. Implicit differentiation keeps the circle in one equation, finds both horizontal tangents from $y'=0$, and recognizes the vertical tangents from a denominator of $0$ in $y'=-\frac{x}{y}$. The four tangent conditions are properties of one relation.
The circle $x^2+y^2=25$ has horizontal tangents at $(0,5)$ and $(0,-5)$, where $y'=-\frac{x}{y}=0$. It has vertical tangents at $(5,0)$ and $(-5,0)$, where $y=0$ and the slope is undefined.
Key points
- Differentiate $x^2+y^2=25$ implicitly to get $2x+2yy'=0$, so $y'=-\frac{x}{y}$ when $y\ne 0$.
- Horizontal tangents: $y'=0$, so $x=0$, giving $(0,5)$ and $(0,-5)$.
- Vertical tangents: $y=0$ and the equation $2x+2yy'=0$ has no finite solution, giving $(5,0)$ and $(-5,0)$.
- The tangent lines are $y=5$, $y=-5$, $x=5$, and $x=-5$.
- Keep the relation intact. Solving for $y$ splits the circle and hides the vertical tangents as endpoints of two separate formulas.
A common mistake is to see an undefined value of $y'=-\frac{x}{y}$ and conclude that the curve has no tangent there. At $(5,0)$ and $(-5,0)$ the denominator is zero and the differentiated equation $2x+2yy'=0$ cannot be solved for a finite slope. Those points have vertical tangent lines $x=5$ and $x=-5$.