TOPIC 2.8 · STUDY

The Product Rule

The product rule says the derivative of $uv$ is $u'v+uv'$, not $u'v'$. For $u=x^2$ and $v=x+1$, the product is $x^3+x^2$ and both methods give $3x^2+2x$. At $x=2$ that derivative equals $16$. A step to $2.1$ produces the nearby quotient $16.71$.

FUN-3.B

The product rule

When two non-constant factors are multiplied, differentiating each factor and multiplying those derivatives is wrong. The extra cross terms matter. If $u$ and $v$ are differentiable, then $\frac{d}{dx}[u v]=u' v+u v'$. In words: derivative of the first times the second, plus the first times the derivative of the second. Either order of the two summands is fine.

The rule is forced by the limit. The change in a product is $u(x+h)v(x+h)-u(x)v(x)$. Add and subtract $u(x+h)v(x)$ in the middle and the difference splits into $u(x+h)$ times the change in $v$, plus $v(x)$ times the change in $u$. Divide by $h$, then let $h \to 0$. You get $u v'+u' v$. The naive product $u'v'$ never appears.

Use the rule when expanding is messy. When the factors are short polynomials, expand as well and compare. Agreement of the two expressions is the check. A constant factor is not a reason to use the product rule: $\frac{d}{dx}[5x^2]=10x$ by the constant-multiple rule. Save the product rule for two factors that both depend on $x$.

The product polynomial y = x cubed plus x squared, and its derivative y = 3 x squared plus 2x.

The teal curve is the product $(x^2)(x+1)=x^3+x^2$. The brown curve is $3x^2+2x$, its derivative. At $x=2$ the product has height $12$ and the derivative curve has height $16$, so the slope of the product is $16$.

Set $u=x^2$ and $v=x+1$. Then $u'=2x$ and $v'=1$, the second because $\frac{d}{dx}[x]+\frac{d}{dx}[1]=1$. The product rule writes $\frac{d}{dx}[x^2(x+1)]=2x(x+1)+x^2(1)=2x^2+2x+x^2=3x^2+2x$.

Expand first and differentiate the polynomial. $x^2(x+1)=x^3+x^2$, and the power and sum rules give $3x^2+2x$. The two methods produce the same function, not merely the same number at one input. At $x=2$ either expression equals $3(4)+2(2)=12+4=16$. The product-rule form gives the same arithmetic before combining: $u'(2)v(2)+u(2)v'(2)=4 \cdot 3+4 \cdot 1=12+4=16$.

A short step agrees approximately. At $x=2.1$, $2.1^3=9.261$ and $2.1^2=4.41$, so the product is $9.261+4.41=13.671$. The value at $x=2$ is $8+4=12$. The quotient is $\frac{13.671-12}{0.1}=\frac{1.671}{0.1}=16.71$, near $16$. The extra $0.71$ is the leftover from a step that has not yet gone to $0$. If the mistaken rule $u'v'$ were used, the derivative would be $2x$, which equals $4$ at $x=2$, nowhere near $16.71$.

Method Derivative At $x=2$
Expand, then differentiate $3x^2+2x$ $12+4=16$
Product rule, then simplify $2x(x+1)+x^2=3x^2+2x$ $4\cdot 3+4\cdot 1=16$
Wrong rule $u'v'$ $2x$ $4$, which the step $16.71$ rejects

Leave an answer in factored form when it is simpler, but simplify before you evaluate. The unsimplified $2x(x+1)+x^2$ and the simplified $3x^2+2x$ are equal as functions, which you can see by expanding the first. Either form is an acceptable derivative if the algebra is correct. A later tangent-line problem wants the number, so substitute the input only after the derivative is written.

Key points

  • $(uv)'=u'v+uv'$. It is not $u'v'$.
  • $(x^2)(x+1)=x^3+x^2$, and both the product rule and the expanded polynomial give $3x^2+2x$.
  • At $x=2$ the derivative is $16$. The height of the product is $12$.
  • The quotient from $2$ to $2.1$ is $16.71$, near $16$ and far from the wrong value $4$.
  • A constant factor uses the constant-multiple rule, not the product rule.

A common mistake is to multiply the derivatives of the factors. For $(x^2)(x+1)$ that error produces $2x$, and at $x=2$ it produces $4$ instead of $16$.

Practice this topic