TOPIC 2.4 · STUDY
Connecting Differentiability and Continuity: Determining When Derivatives Do and Do Not Exist
A derivative at a point can exist only if the function is continuous there, but continuity is not enough. The graph of $y=|x|$ is continuous at the origin and has a corner: the left-hand slope is $-1$ and the right-hand slope is $1$, so there is no tangent slope. A vertical tangent and a cusp are two further ways a finite derivative can fail.
FUN-2.A
Continuity, corners, and other places a derivative fails
Differentiability is the stronger condition. If $f'(a)$ exists, then $f$ is continuous at $a$. The reason is short. The difference $f(x)-f(a)$ equals the difference quotient times $(x-a)$. As $x$ approaches $a$, the quotient approaches the finite slope $f'(a)$ and the factor $(x-a)$ approaches $0$, so their product approaches $0$. Therefore $f(x)$ approaches $f(a)$.
The converse is false. A graph can be unbroken at a point and still have no single tangent slope. The standard corner is $f(x)=|x|$ at $x=0$. The function is continuous there because both sides approach $0$, and $f(0)=0$. The slopes on the two sides do not agree.
Two rays meet at $(0,0)$. Left of the origin the graph is the line $y=-x$, slope $-1$. Right of the origin it is $y=x$, slope $1$. The graph never breaks, but it has no single tangent line at the corner.
Check the one-sided quotients with algebra. For $h>0$, $\frac{|0+h|-|0|}{h}=\frac{h}{h}=1$. For $h<0$, $|h|=-h$, so $\frac{-h}{h}=-1$. The right-hand limit of the difference quotient is $1$ and the left-hand limit is $-1$. A limit exists only when those one-sided limits exist and are equal. They are not, so $f'(0)$ does not exist.
The same corner, labeled by its one-sided slopes. A tangent would need one slope. Here the left-hand slope is $-1$ and the right-hand slope is $+1$.
A break in the graph is a simpler failure. If $f$ is not continuous at $a$, it cannot be differentiable there, because differentiability would have forced continuity. In the difference quotient, if $f(x)-f(a)$ refuses to approach $0$, dividing by a tiny $x-a$ makes the quotient blow up or jump. Holes and jumps both block the derivative.
Two smoother-looking failures still have no finite derivative. A vertical tangent is a curve that passes through the point in one connected piece but stands straight up, so the steepness is not a finite number. The cube-root graph $y=x^{1/3}$ does this at the origin: it is continuous there, and it has no finite slope. A cusp is sharper than a corner. On $y=x^{2/3}$ the graph comes to a thorn at the origin; the one-sided slopes are infinite and point in opposite directions. You do not need those formulas to differentiate anything yet. You need the pictures: a vertical wall is not a finite slope, and a thorn is not a corner with two finite slopes either.
| Local picture | Continuous there? | Finite derivative? |
|---|---|---|
| Smooth bend, such as $y=x^2$ | Yes | Yes |
| Corner, such as $y=|x|$ at $0$ | Yes | No: slopes $-1$ and $1$ |
| Hole or jump | No | No |
| Vertical tangent, such as $y=x^{1/3}$ at $0$ | Yes | No: slope is not finite |
| Cusp, such as $y=x^{2/3}$ at $0$ | Yes | No: a thorn, not a finite slope |
On a graph, scan for corners, cusps, vertical tangents, holes, and jumps before you trust a slope. On a formula built from polynomials, sine, cosine, and exponentials in the ways this unit allows, the derivative exists on the domain you are using. Absolute values, piecewise definitions, and denominators that hit zero are the situations that need the one-sided check.
Key points
- If $f'(a)$ exists, then $f$ is continuous at $a$. The difference $f(x)-f(a)$ is the quotient times $(x-a)$, which approaches a finite slope times $0$.
- The converse is false. $y=|x|$ is continuous at $0$ and not differentiable there.
- At that corner the right-hand quotient is $1$ and the left-hand quotient is $-1$.
- A discontinuity also blocks the derivative.
- A vertical tangent and a cusp are continuous pictures with no finite derivative.
A common mistake is to treat continuity as permission to differentiate. An unbroken graph can still have a corner. Check the one-sided slopes before you claim $f'(a)$ exists.