TOPIC 1.3 · STUDY
Estimating Limit Values from Graphs
On a graph, a limit is the height the curve approaches. A hole or a separate closed dot can change the function value without changing that height. The two-sided limit exists only when the left-hand and right-hand heights agree.
LIM-1.C
Estimating a limit from a graph
A graph lets you estimate a limit by watching height as $x$ slides toward a vertical line. Follow the curve from the left until you are close to the target $x$-value, and read the $y$-value you are approaching. Do the same from the right. If those heights agree at a number $L$, then $\lim_{x\to a} f(x)=L$.
The figure is the line $y=x-2$ with an open circle at $(3,1)$ and a closed dot at $(3,4)$. The line itself gives the approached height: at $x=3$, $3-2=1$, so the open circle sits at height $1$. From the left, the line arrives at that height. From the right, the same line arrives at that height. The closed dot is a different piece of information: it says $f(3)=4$.
So $\lim_{x\to 3} f(x)=1$, while $f(3)=4$. The gap between those readings is $4-1=3$, and that gap belongs to the function value, not to the limit. An open circle on the approached height does not cancel the limit. A closed dot off the curve does not move the limit.
| What you see near $x=a$ | Limit conclusion | Function value |
|---|---|---|
| Both sides approach height $L$, even through a hole | $\lim_{x\to a} f(x)=L$ | may be missing |
| Both sides approach $L$, and a closed dot sits at $L$ | limit is $L$ | $f(a)=L$ |
| Both sides approach $L$, but the closed dot is elsewhere | limit is still $L$ | $f(a)$ is the dot |
| Left height and right height differ | two-sided limit does not exist | the dot, if any, is separate |
| The curve climbs or falls past every bound | no finite limit on that side | often undefined |
Both sides of $y=x-2$ approach height $1$ at $x=3$, so the limit is $1$. The closed dot records $f(3)=4$.
A jump is the graph version of unequal one-sided limits. If the left piece approaches height $2$ and the right piece approaches height $5$, you can write $\lim_{x\to a^-} f(x)=2$ and $\lim_{x\to a^+} f(x)=5$, and you stop there for the two-sided limit. Averaging $2$ and $5$ to get $3.5$ invents a height the graph never approaches.
A corner, such as the meeting of two rays at one shared height, still has a limit. The limit asks only whether the heights settle. Sharp turns matter later, when the question becomes whether a tangent line exists.
Key points
- Read a two-sided limit by checking the height approached from the left and from the right.
- On $y=x-2$, the hole at $x=3$ is at height $3-2=1$, so $\lim_{x\to 3} f(x)=1$.
- A closed dot at a different height is $f(a)$. Here $f(3)=4$.
- If the one-sided heights differ, the two-sided limit does not exist.
- A hole on the approached height does not erase a finite limit.
A common mistake is to read the closed dot as the limit. On this graph the dot is $4$ and the limit is $1$.