TOPIC 1.13 · STUDY

Removing Discontinuities

A discontinuity at x=a can be removed when the two-sided limit exists and is finite. Define or redefine f(a) to equal that limit. A jump or an infinite break cannot be removed by one function value.

LIM-2.C

Filling a hole with the limit value

A discontinuity at $x=a$ is removable when $\lim_{x\to a} f(x)$ exists and is a real number. The repair is to define, or redefine, $f(a)$ so that it equals that limit. After the repair, the three continuity requirements hold at $x=a$: the value exists, the limit exists, and they match.

Start with $f(x)=\dfrac{x^2-1}{x-1}$ for $x\neq 1$, and leave $f(1)$ undefined. Factor: $\dfrac{(x-1)(x+1)}{x-1}=x+1$ whenever $x\neq 1$. Therefore $\lim_{x\to 1} f(x)=1+1=2$. The graph is the line $y=x+1$ with a hole at $(1,2)$. The value that removes the discontinuity is $2$. Define $f(1)=2$. The new function agrees with $y=x+1$ at every input, including $x=1$.

If a formula had already set $f(1)=5$, the limit would still be $2$, and $5\neq 2$, so the function would still be discontinuous at $x=1$. Removing the discontinuity means changing the stored value from $5$ to $2$. Leaving $5$ in place does not repair the hole. The limit, not the old function value, chooses the new number.

Break Limit fact Repair
Hole in $\dfrac{x^2-1}{x-1}$ Limit equals $2$ Set $f(1)=2$
Wrong value $f(1)=5$ Limit is still $2$, and $5\neq 2$ Replace $5$ with $2$
Jump, left limit $2$ and right limit $5$ Two-sided limit does not exist No single value works
$1/x$ at $x=0$ One-sided limits are infinite No finite value works
Graph of (x^2-1)/(x-1) with a hole at (1, 2).

The open circle is at $(1,2)$, the limit of $\dfrac{x^2-1}{x-1}$. That missing height is the value that would remove the discontinuity.

The repaired function y=x+1 with a closed point at (1, 2).

Defining $f(1)=2$ fills the hole. The graph is now the continuous line $y=x+1$, and $1+1=2$ matches both the limit and the function value.

The same test rejects a jump. If the left-hand limit is $2$ and the right-hand limit is $5$, there is no single number $L$ that both sides approach. Setting $f(a)$ equal to $2$, to $5$, or to any other number leaves at least one side unmatched, so the two-sided limit still fails to equal $f(a)$. An infinite discontinuity is blocked for the same structural reason: the outputs do not approach a real number, so there is no real $L$ to assign.

Key points

  • A discontinuity is removable only when the two-sided limit exists and is finite.
  • For $\dfrac{x^2-1}{x-1}$, cancellation gives $x+1$, and the limit at $x=1$ is $2$.
  • Set $f(1)=2$ to remove the hole.
  • A stored value such as $f(1)=5$ must be changed, because $5\neq 2$.
  • Jumps and infinite discontinuities are not removable by one function value.

A common mistake is to set the new function value equal to $0$, or equal to the input $1$, because the original expression was undefined. The repair value is the limit, which here is $1+1=2$.

Practice this topic