TOPIC 1.1 · STUDY
Introducing Calculus: Can Change Occur at an Instant?
An average rate compares change over a whole interval. The rate at an instant is the number those average rates approach when the interval shrinks to that instant, and it is the slope of the tangent line.
CHA-1.A
Average rate and rate at an instant
Calculus begins with a question about change. If a position is given by $s=t^2$, the object is not moving at one fixed speed. Over a long interval the change can look large, while over a tiny interval around one moment the change settles toward a single rate.
The average rate of change of $s$ from $t=a$ to $t=b$ is the slope of the secant line through the two points on the graph: $\dfrac{s(b)-s(a)}{b-a}$. That quotient uses the whole interval. It does not by itself tell you the rate at the single instant $t=a$.
Shrink the interval toward the instant. For $s=t^2$ at $t=1$, the position is $1^2=1$. From $t=1$ to $t=2$, the position goes from $1$ to $4$, so the average rate is $\dfrac{4-1}{2-1}=\dfrac{3}{1}=3$. From $t=1$ to $t=1.5$, the position is $1.5^2=2.25$, and the average rate is $\dfrac{2.25-1}{0.5}=\dfrac{1.25}{0.5}=2.5$. From $t=1$ to $t=1.1$, the position is $1.21$, and $\dfrac{1.21-1}{0.1}=\dfrac{0.21}{0.1}=2.1$. From $t=1$ to $t=1.01$, the position is $1.0201$, and $\dfrac{1.0201-1}{0.01}=\dfrac{0.0201}{0.01}=2.01$.
The average rates $3$, $2.5$, $2.1$, and $2.01$ are heading for $2$. The same exact value comes from algebra. For $t\neq 1$, $\dfrac{t^2-1}{t-1}=\dfrac{(t-1)(t+1)}{t-1}=t+1$. As $t$ approaches $1$, $t+1$ approaches $1+1=2$. The rate at the instant $t=1$ is $2$. The line through $(1,1)$ with slope $2$ is $y-1=2(x-1)$, which simplifies to $y=2x-1$. That line is the tangent line at $x=1$.
| Interval | Average rate | Arithmetic |
|---|---|---|
| $t=1$ to $t=2$ | $3$ | $(4-1)/(2-1)=3$ |
| $t=1$ to $t=1.5$ | $2.5$ | $(2.25-1)/0.5=2.5$ |
| $t=1$ to $t=1.1$ | $2.1$ | $(1.21-1)/0.1=2.1$ |
| $t=1$ to $t=1.01$ | $2.01$ | $(1.0201-1)/0.01=2.01$ |
| instant $t=1$ | $2$ | simplified quotient $t+1\to 2$ |
The secant through $(1,1)$ and $(2,4)$ has slope $3$. The tangent line $y=2x-1$ touches the parabola at $(1,1)$ and has slope $2$, the instantaneous rate.
On the figure the secant is the straight segment from $(1,1)$ to $(2,4)$. At $x=2$ that secant is at height $4$, while the tangent $y=2x-1$ is at height $2\cdot 2-1=3$. The two lines meet at the instant you care about, and they separate as soon as the interval has positive length. Later topics name the instantaneous rate as a derivative. Here the idea is enough: the instant rate is the limit of average rates.
Key points
- Average rate on $[a,b]$ is $\dfrac{s(b)-s(a)}{b-a}$, the slope of a secant.
- The rate at an instant is the value those average rates approach as the interval shrinks to that instant.
- For $s=t^2$ at $t=1$, the average rates approach $2$, and $(t^2-1)/(t-1)=t+1$ for $t\neq 1$.
- The tangent line at $(1,1)$ is $y=2x-1$. Its slope is the instantaneous rate.
- A secant slope over a wide interval is a different number from the rate at one endpoint.
A common mistake is to report the secant slope $3$ as the rate at $t=1$. That $3$ averages every moment from $1$ to $2$. The instant $t=1$ has rate $2$.